In the world of BBC's prison drama Time, Jodie Whittaker's poignant line echoes the profound transformation her character undergoes. From a life filled with a house, a job, and a family, she finds herself stripped of everything upon entering the unforgiving confines of incarceration. Orla, a single mother to three young children, faces a six-month sentence for tampering with her electricity meter – an act she colloquially terms as "fiddling the leccy."
As Time unfurls its narrative, it lays bare the harsh consequences of Orla's actions. This brief stint behind bars will cost her not just her job and home but also the heart-wrenching separation from her children, placed in foster care. The series prompts viewers to question the justification for such severe repercussions, asking whether the crime lies in the simple inability to afford keeping the lights on.
The harsh reality portrayed in Time reflects a broader societal issue. Despite women constituting 51 percent of the population in England and Wales, they make up less than five percent of the prison demographic. A House of Commons committee report from the previous year highlights that women often receive sentences for non-violent, low-level, yet persistent offenses. In 2020, a staggering 72 percent of women entering prison had committed non-violent crimes. Notably, three out of five women serve sentences of less than six months, painting a grim picture of a system seemingly ill-equipped to address their unique challenges.
Time, a creation of renowned screenwriter Jimmy McGovern, takes a compelling leap from its initial focus on a fictional men's prison to shed light on the often overlooked stories within the women's prison estate. McGovern, known for his work on acclaimed shows like Cracker and The Street, brought on screenwriter Helen Black to infuse authenticity into the narrative. Black, with her background in law and contributions to powerful projects like the BBC Three film Life and Death in the Warehouse, lends both professional insight and personal understanding of the criminal justice process to the series.
The shift in focus prompts a crucial exploration of why prison life diverges significantly for women. Time endeavors to capture the nuanced challenges faced by female prisoners within a system seemingly designed with men in mind. As the series unfolds, it aims to authentically portray the frustrations and complexities of these often-neglected stories, inviting viewers to contemplate the efficacy of a system that, time and again, appears to fail its female constituents.
In the upcoming series, Jodie Whittaker's character, Orla, takes center stage as one of three compelling women, each navigating their own tumultuous paths within the prison system. The trio includes Kelsey, a young and pregnant heroin addict portrayed by Bella Ramsey from The Last of Us, and Tamara Lawrance's Abi, serving a life sentence while harboring a secret from her fellow inmates.
Screenwriter Helen Black and creator Jimmy McGovern drew inspiration from real-life insights gathered during conversations with prisoners at HMP Styal, a closed-category women's prison in Cheshire. The vivid portrayal of living conditions in the series reflects the stark reality of approximately 20 women sharing a house, complete with communal bedrooms, bathrooms, a kitchen, and a TV room. This setting stands in stark contrast to the long, grey corridors depicted in the first season of Time. Black emphasizes the peculiar dynamic of these living arrangements, where women, irrespective of the nature of their crimes or legal status, coexist within the confines of these shared spaces. Despite the apparent freedom to move within the house, the front door remains locked.
The narrative delves into the challenges posed by short sentences, exemplified by Orla's predicament. These brief incarcerations allow minimal time for rehabilitation, yet are sufficient to dismantle prisoners' lives, causing them to lose jobs, homes, and family connections. The result is a disturbing cycle where individuals find themselves back in the prison system, akin to a revolving door. Ella, drawing from her firsthand experience of spending just over a year in prison before collaborating with Working Chance, a charity supporting women with convictions, describes Orla's case as a "textbook example of how the system operates." She emphasizes the systemic shortcomings, suggesting that a more compassionate approach, involving support and a modest investment, could break this cycle. Ella advocates for understanding the context behind the actions, particularly in cases like Orla's, where the character, while breaking the law, was driven by a desire to care for her children. In her view, a bit of financial assistance and support could preserve the family unit and prevent the revolving door from claiming yet another individual.
Helen Black, the creative force behind the new series, concurs with a sentiment that seems almost absurd on the surface: the cost of imprisoning individuals exceeds the financial investment required to alleviate their struggles. Pointing to Ministry of Justice figures from 2021, which revealed an average annual cost of £48,409 per prisoner, Black questions the logic of a system that seemingly opts for ruin over rehabilitation. Emphasizing the importance of depicting ordinary lives torn apart by incarceration on the show, she raises a crucial query: who truly benefits from incarcerating individuals like Orla, who posed no threat to herself or society?
Even for those holding strong opinions on crime and punishment, Black argues that common sense and financial considerations indicate the irrationality of short sentences. The impact of female imprisonment is particularly profound because, as Black notes, women often serve as the linchpin of a family unit. Unlike male prisoners who may have relatives awaiting their release, female prisoners frequently find themselves at the core of familial connections, intensifying the ongoing effects of their incarceration.
In the series Time, the heartbreaking unraveling of Orla's family dynamic, where she becomes estranged from her teenage son placed in foster care with his younger siblings, underscores the devastating consequences of maternal imprisonment. Statistics reveal that 95 percent of children must leave their homes when their mothers go to jail, affecting approximately 17,000 children annually in England and Wales. Saj Zafar, the first Asian woman to serve as a UK prison governor, emphasizes the reality that removing the woman from the equation often leads to the collapse of the entire family structure.
Ella, drawing from her experience working in a women's prison, sheds light on a concerning practice where some female prisoners may choose not to disclose information about their families out of fear of social services involvement. The fear of losing custody leads some mothers to withhold information about their children, creating a complex dynamic where transparency becomes a perceived threat. The dilemma faced by these women is stark – admit to having children and risk social services intervention or deny it to maintain control over a precarious situation. This nuanced aspect further underscores the intricate web of challenges faced by female prisoners within the system.
In 2018, a study from the University of Liverpool uncovered a concerning disparity: women were found to be twice as likely as men to receive harsher sentences for assault offenses involving alcohol. This prompts a crucial question about potential double standards in sentencing. Saj Zafar delves into the psychology at play, highlighting societal acceptance when a man, in an intoxicated state, engages in violent behavior. The perception that such actions are "normal" or "expected" for men raises questions about the fairness of the judicial system.
The series Time, while unapologetically exposing the flaws within the prison complex, refrains from presenting its officers as mere caricatures. Zafar points out the common portrayal of prison staff as abusive and egotistical on TV, contrasting it with the reality where, more often than not, officers genuinely care about the well-being of the prisoners. In a departure from the stereotypical portrayal, the series portrays the palpable frustration of officers within a flawed system. Ella emphasizes the empathy displayed by some officers in the series, echoing the reality that genuine care can foster positive relationships between staff and inmates.
However, the challenges faced by imprisoned women go beyond sentencing disparities. Mental health issues, particularly prevalent among women, affect over 70 percent of female prisoners. Helen Black notes the additional complexities related to pregnancy and childbirth, a theme powerfully explored in Bella Ramsey's storyline. Additionally, almost two-thirds of incarcerated women are believed to have experienced domestic abuse. Ella draws attention to the grim reality that many women she encountered in prison were in long-term abusive relationships. It was often a breaking point, a moment of snapping back or protecting a child, that led to police involvement and subsequent convictions.
As Time unfolds the narratives of its characters, it unflinchingly explores the multifaceted reasons why women find themselves in prison, shedding light on societal and systemic factors contributing to their incarceration. The series, in its raw portrayal of prison life, underscores the need for empathy, understanding, and reform within the criminal justice system.
In the realm of fictional HMP Carlingford depicted in the series Time, one character, portrayed by Jodie Whittaker, challenges the prevailing narrative of violence that often permeates prison portrayals in media. She questions the omnipresence of makeshift weapons, exemplified by a shank in a later episode, and wonders why every prison representation seems to be steeped in an underlying core of violence. The character, however, acknowledges the need for dramatization in television, recognizing the impracticality of showcasing women in prison engaged in mundane activities like crochet and reading.
The series aligns with a broader societal backdrop where progress in creating alternatives to custodial sentences for women remains limited. Despite the Female Offender Strategy's goal of reducing the number of female prisoners, the Ministry of Justice anticipates a 30 percent increase in the female prison population by 2025. Controversial plans to add 500 more prison places for women in England further underscore the challenges in shifting the narrative.
Last year, the Justice Committee acknowledged the need for alternatives to custodial sentences, and despite the ongoing challenges, the government earmarked £15 million in May to support organizations aiding women in the justice system, particularly those involved in lower-level offenses. Justice Secretary Alex Chalk also announced plans to eliminate sentences of under 12 months for most crimes, excluding violent or sexual offenses.
Screenwriter Helen Black maintains a pragmatic perspective on the impact of television, stating that dramas may not directly change laws or policies but can instigate vital conversations. She believes in the power of viewers engaging with the content and fostering discussions, ultimately shining a light on pertinent issues.
As Orla, Kelsey, and Abi's stories unfold on screen, they are poised to leave a lasting impression on viewers, transcending the confines of the television screen and sparking conversations about the complexities of the justice system, particularly concerning women.
By choosing to 'Create my account' or 'Register,' you confirm the accuracy of your entered data and acknowledge that you have read and agreed to our Terms of Use, Cookie Policy, and Privacy Notice. This website is safeguarded by reCAPTCHA, and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply. If you already have an account, simply 'Sign in' to continue engaging in thought-provoking conversations and following other Independent readers. The series captivates with its exploration of the complexities surrounding women entering prison, depicted through the intertwining stories of Kelsey, Orla, and Abi, who find themselves incarcerated on the same day. Tamara Lawrance, Bella Ramsey, and Jodie Whittaker bring depth to their characters, underscoring the rough justice prevalent in their fictional world. If you wish to revisit your favorite articles or stories later, consider starting your Independent Premium subscription today. Your journey into thought-provoking narratives awaits.
In conclusion, the series delves into the intricate and often harsh realities of women navigating the criminal justice system, portraying the lives of Kelsey, Orla, and Abi with raw authenticity. The characters, portrayed by Tamara Lawrance, Bella Ramsey, and Jodie Whittaker, bring depth to the challenges faced by women entering prison. The narrative challenges stereotypes and prompts viewers to reflect on the societal and systemic factors that contribute to women's incarceration.
As the characters grapple with the consequences of their actions, the series sheds light on the broader issues within the justice system, touching on sentencing disparities, mental health challenges, and the impact of domestic abuse. The juxtaposition of fictional HMP Carlingford challenges common media portrayals of violence in prison, prompting a thoughtful exploration of the complexities involved.
Amidst the nuanced storytelling, the text touches on real-world challenges, including limited progress in creating alternatives to custodial sentences for women. The government's plans for additional prison spaces for women and ongoing efforts to address these issues are discussed, emphasizing the need for continued dialogue and reform.
Screenwriter Helen Black remains pragmatic about the role of television in influencing change, emphasizing the power of thought-provoking conversations sparked by dramas like Time. The stories of Orla, Kelsey, and Abi linger in the minds of viewers, encouraging a deeper understanding of the multifaceted challenges faced by women within the justice system. Ultimately, the series serves as a poignant reminder of the importance of empathy, reform, and ongoing discourse in addressing the complexities surrounding women in prison.